In a move both predictable and morally repulsive, Israel has ordered the demolition of the homes of two Palestinians from the occupied West Bank who carried out a shooting at a Jerusalem bus stop, killing six people. Alongside, the government has revoked work permits for hundreds of villagers. These measures are not justice—they are collective punishment, plain and simple.
What’s Being Done
Defense Minister Israel Katz has directed the destruction of structures in the villages of Qatanna and Qubeiba that were built without permits and the state is revoking work permits from some 750 people in those same villages—many of whom depend on those permits for income. National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has also pushed for expanding gun-licensing among Israelis, framing civilians with weapons as part of the answer to terrorism.
Why This Is Not Justified, but Illegal
1. Collective Punishment Is Forbidden Under International Law
The Fourth Geneva Convention (Article 33) expressly prohibits collective penalties and reprisals against protected persons for acts they did not commit. Legal scholarship confirms that administrative punishments—such as demolishing homes or revoking permits—targeting innocent civilians are classic collective punishments.
2. Deterrence Does Not Excuse Violations
Israel argues these measures are deterrents. But deterrence cannot override absolute prohibitions in humanitarian law. Punishing people who had no role in the attack—revoking the livelihood of neighbors, destroying property of uninvolved family members—crosses moral and legal lines.
3. The Innocent Suffer
Children, elders, neighbors—all become collateral damage. The loss of a home, loss of income, constant fear: these are not effects of war; they are punishment for collective belonging. There is no legal defense for punishing people simply because of geography or family ties.
When a state embraces such measures, it erodes its own claim to moral legitimacy. The rule-of-law demands individual responsibility, not guilt by association. Far from deterring violence, collective punishment is more likely to fuel hatred, revenge, radicalization. It doesn’t heal; it aggravates.
These actions place Israel further outside respect for international norms. International bodies, human rights groups, and treaties are unequivocal that collective punishment is a war crime. Continued practice undermines diplomatic credibility and could expose Israeli leaders to legal risk.
©TNPP
Discover more from The New Palestine Post
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
